High but not in the elite group for me.
Guys like Hogan, Austin, Bret, HBK, Taker, Flair, Rock are in that top tier, but i'd say Savage is in that second tier.
He had a "Classic" match with steamboat and was an essential part of WWF/WWE/WCW at different times.
I was never a massive fan... but the steamboat match was fantastic (and he was a good worker) and the whole Elizabeth moment was great. I remember the feud with Warrior/Flair & Perfect going into Summerslam 92. great stuff.
He was great at interacting with the fans.
Such a tragedy and he will surely take his place in the HOF.