Chris Jericho - 5
John Cena - 4
Jericho will score steady always. Even if he was to lose the title he'd still hold up his baragain as a No1 pick. I think he was the logical pick and not "thinking outside the box". Especially with both World Title pictures looking less than clear. I mean is Jeff Hardy a long time champion... Does SD have a potential long term champion? and RAW has HHH, Cena & Orton all with desires of the title and any of them could walk out of SS with that title and even then for how long.
Jericho is a brilliant pick.
Cena is a definate 5 with the title and as champion for the majority of the game would be the top scorer. However without the title doesn't have the same affect as D found out in the last game.
I believe there are 4 5* picks and one is gone.